FHSAA Final Four: 2008: 2009
FHSAA Regional Champions: 2008; 2009
FHSAA Regional Playoffs: 2006; 2007; 2008; 2009; 2022; 2023; 2024
FHSAA District Champions: 2006; 2007; 2008; 2009
FHSAA District Runner-Ups: 2015; 2016; 2017; 2018; 2022; 2023; 2024
Saint Augustine Record Player of the Year
2018: Ashton Wood
Florida State Lacrosse Coaches Association (FSLCA) All-State Team
2020: Matthew Pounder
Florida State Lacrosse Coaches Association (FSLCA) All-Senior Recognition
2019: Tucker Albritton, D
2020: Matthew Pounder, D/LSM
2021: Christian House, FOGO
2021: Tyler Rueppell, D
2021: Bryce Pegram, M
2022: Nick Fleming, A
North Florida US Lacrosse Academic All Americans
2010: Justin Lucas
2011: Jake McVeagh
2012: Mitch Wilson
2013: Danny Hutton
2016: Ian Areford
2017: Sean Howard
2022: Nick Fleming
2023: Jaxon Vu
2024: Nik Perkins
North Florida US Lacrosse All Americans
2009: Brett Angerer
2009: Matt Leighty
2010: Erik Carson
2011: Erik Carson
2018: Ashton Wood
2018: Phil Mylet
2023: CJ Miller
North Florida US Lacrosse Coach of the Year
2017: Coach Max Gurowski